Here’s a look at selected districts in Harris County that shows the range of votes and vote percentages achieved by Democratic candidates. I’ve thrown in the Obama and Sam Houston results from 2008 for each to provide a comparison between how the district was predicted to perform and how it actually did perform. Without further ado:
HD132 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 22,336 43.52
Ryan 20,945 40.63
Bennett 20,454 40.35
Obama 21,116 40.29
Oliver 19,873 38.52
08Obama 18,886 39.60
08Houston 18,653 40.60
HD132, which runs out to the western edge of Harris County, incorporating parts of Katy, is a fascinating district. For one thing, as Greg showed, there are these fairly large blue patches out that way, surrounded otherwise by a sea of red. Much of that blue is in HD132, which is why this district wound up overperforming its 2008 numbers by about a point. As Greg said in reply to my comment on that post, you could build a pretty reasonable Democratic district out that way if you were in control of the mapmaking process. In fact, the non-MALDEF intervenors in the San Antonio lawsuit did propose a map that drew HD132 as a lean-Dem district. It wasn’t addressed by the DC court in its ruling denying preclearance on the maps, so we won’t see any such district this decade, but just as the old 132 came on the radar in 2008, the new HD132 should be viewed as an attainable goal, perhaps in 2016. Take the continued population dynamics of Harris County, add in a good candidate and a concerted voter registration/GOTV effort, and I think you could have something.
HD134 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 36,781 48.07
Ryan 35,431 45.96
Johnson 36,366 45.35
Obama 34,561 42.49
Bennett 29,843 39.47
Oliver 25,886 33.79
08Obama 39,153 46.50
08Houston 33,667 42.60
I think you’ll be hard-pressed to find a district with a wider vote spread than HD134. A couple things stand out to me. One is that four years ago in the old 134, President Obama ran five points ahead of Democratic judicial candidates. I haven’t done the math on the judicials this time around – even in Excel/Calc, it gets mighty tedious after awhile – but I’d bet money that’s not the case this year. I’d call this evidence of Obama losing ground with Anglo voters in Texas, as he did nationwide. Note also that Adrian Garcia did not carry HD134 this time around, unlike in 2008 when he was the only Democrat besides then-Rep. Ellen Cohen to win it. (Michael Skelly, running in CD07, carried the portion of HD134 that was in CD07, which was most but not quite all of it.) Garcia’s overall performance was a couple of points lower this year, but this shows how tough HD134 really was, something which I think wasn’t fully appreciated by most observers. Ann Johnson ran hard and did a good job, but the hill was too steep. I’m sure HD134 will remain a tempting target, but the name of the game here is persuasion, not turnout, and that’s a harder task.
HD135 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 23,507 44.91
Ryan 21,620 41.26
Obama 21,679 40.37
Bennett 20,786 40.26
Morgan 20,997 39.63
Oliver 20,119 38.42
08Obama 20,430 38.70
08Houston 19,912 39.50
Another not-on-the-radar district that wound up being better for Dems than you would have expected. As with HD132, this would be a good place to focus registration and turnout energies going forward.
HD137 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 15,682 67.58
Ryan 15,498 65.88
Wu 15,789 65.72
Obama 15,899 65.25
Bennett 14,875 64.63
Oliver 14,700 62.62
08Obama 16,755 62.30
08Houston 16,008 62.40
I haven’t looked this deeply at all of the Democratic districts, but the early indicators are that Democratic candidates generally outperformed the 2008 numbers in the districts that were considered to be competitive. Even by the 2008 numbers, HD137 wasn’t particularly competitive, but with a first-time candidate in an open seat against someone who’d won elections in the same general vicinity before and who could write his own check, who knew what could happen. Rep.-elect Gene Wu had a strong showing in a district where all Dems did well. I mean, if Lloyd Oliver outperformed Obama 08, you know Democrats kicked butt in this district.
HD144 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 13,555 57.96
Ryan 12,668 53.96
Bennett 12,382 53.63
Perez 12,425 53.35
Obama 12,281 51.47
Oliver 11,966 51.07
08Obama 11,983 48.00
08Houston 13,129 54.50
The disparity between Obama and Sam Houston in 08 makes it a little hard to pin this district down as overperforming or underperforming. It’s fair to say that Rep.-elect Mary Ann Perez won by a more comfortable margin than most people, myself included, might have expected, and it appears that Obama closed the gap a bit this year. This will surely be a race to watch in 2014, whether or not the district gets tweaked by the courts or the Lege. (The DC court rejected the intervenors’ claims about retrogression in HD144, in case you were curious.) Oh, and I hadn’t thought about this before now, but Perez’s win means that there will need to be a special election for her HCC Trustee position in 2013. I have no idea off the top of my head what the procedures are for that.
HD145 Votes Pct
========================
Alvarado 20,829 68.86
Garcia 19,180 67.67
Ryan 17,860 63.04
Obama 17,890 61.13
Bennett 17,252 61.90
Oliver 16,778 59.22
08Obama 16,749 57.10
08Houston 17,315 61.70
Rep. Alvarado was unopposed, so the percentage shown for her is her share of all ballots cast in HD145. I was a little concerned about the possibility of Republicans maybe stealing this seat in a special election if Rep. Alvarado wins in SD06 – one possible incentive for Rick Perry to shake a leg on calling that special election is that he could then call the special election for HD145 in May if that seat gets vacated, as surely that would guarantee the lowest turnout – but I’m less concerned about it looking at these numbers. Yes, I know, the electoral conditions would be totally different, but still. By my count there were 7,013 straight-ticket Republican votes in this district and 12,293 straight-ticket D votes. I think even in a low-turnout context, that would be a tall order for a Republican candidate.
HD148 Votes Pct
========================
Farrar 25,921 64.56
Garcia 23,776 63.87
Ryan 22,413 59.91
Obama 22,393 57.92
Bennett 21,061 57.80
Oliver 19,848 53.34
08Obama 22,338 57.50
08Houston 21,887 59.20
Rep. Farrar had a Green opponent but no R opponent, so as with Rep. Alvarado her percentage is that of the total number of ballots cast. Again, one’s perception of this district as slightly overperforming or slightly underperforming for Dems depends on whether one thinks the Obama or Houston number from 2008 is the more accurate measure of the district from that year. Given the re-honkification of the Heights, I feel like this district needs to be watched in the same way that HD132 needs to be watched, only in the other direction. I feel certain that if there is to be any change in the makeup of HD148, it will happen a lot more slowly than in HD132, but nonetheless it bears watching. I’ll reassess in 2016 as needed. Oh, and there were 9,672 straight-ticket Republican votes to 13,259 straight-ticket D votes here, in case you were wondering.
HD149 Votes Pct
========================
Vo 25,967 61.12
Garcia 25,056 60.64
Ryan 24,325 58.61
Obama 24,770 57.72
Bennett 23,659 57.64
Oliver 23,337 56.27
08Obama 24,426 55.50
08Houston 23,544 56.30
If you wanted to know why I tend to worry less about Rep. Hubert Vo than I do about some other Dems and districts, this would be why. Anyone who can outdo Adrian Garcia is someone with strong crossover appeal. Note again the general overperformance of Dems here compared to 2008. Consider this some evidence of Asian-American voters trending even more blue this cycle.
SBOE6 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 229,058 43.48
Ryan 216,249 40.88
Jensen 207,697 40.58
Obama 215,053 39.33
Bennett 199,169 38.27
Oliver 188,555 35.69
08Obama 224,088 40.80
08Houston 210,965 40.20
I was hopeful that Dems could build on 2008 in this district, but it wasn’t to be. I think the potential is there going forward, but it will take time and resources. Traci Jensen was a great candidate, who ran hard as the first Democrat in SBOE6 in over 20 years, but there’s only so much you can do in a district twice the size of a Congressional district without a Congressional-size campaign budget.
CD07 Votes Pct
========================
Garcia 99,355 43.93
Ryan 93,819 41.30
Obama 92,128 39.13
Bennett 84,451 37.73
Cargas 85,253 37.44
Oliver 79,037 34.83
08Obama 96,866 40.40
08Houston 88,957 39.10
As with SBOE6, a small step back in performance instead of the step forward I had hoped for. Not sure if it was something John Culberson did to enable him to run ahead of the pack instead of lagging behind it as he did in 2006 and 2008, or if James Cargas’ weak performance had something to do with the ridiculously bitter primary runoff he was in. Be that as it may, I don’t expect much if anything to be different in this district in the near future.
Pingback: Callegari to retire – Off the Kuff
Pingback: He’s baaaack – Off the Kuff